Why didn't she sing??

[Hownee]

Why didn't hannah sing?

I'm sure that there were lots of kids who could sing that would add more to the group than she did.

I'm not saying that she wasn't a good group member... i liked her... but what i'm saying is true.

[Clare C. G]

she sang on some of the b-sides and album tracks.

[gummiebearz]

lol yea i wished she could of sang some more ;) she sang a lot of the background singing here and there lol :p i really wish they would let her sing some more lol because i think they should all get there chances to sing a lot :D

[Hownee]

In wich songs did she have a leading part?

[AaronsGirl]

I dont think anyone knows for sure why hannah didnt sing more. maybe she blended better with them and was stronger with the background vocals then as a solo. I think alot of people wish she had sang more. They must have seen something in Hannah to pick her over others that were there, but maybe didnt think she was as strong as some of the others in the group for a solo part.

[arjaco1]

she never seemed very confident compared to others on stage so probably never even wanted to. She was 11 when she started and if i was 11 i wouldnt really wanna sing!!

[clairebear]

yeah but dont forget she was chosen AFTER the others just like Aaron, maybe they thought she looked cute for the band, and was a good dancer and an alright voice

[Rochelle and Frankie's_boy]

I know she was always in the background

[gummiebearz]

lol yea i think she just didn't really suit maybe having a solo.. maybe not strong enough? but she probably has a really harmonious voice because they always put her in the background singing :D lol and yea there must of been something special about her to get her picked lol :p but then the thing with aaron and hannah getting picked afterwards is that aaron still gets solos here and there and quite often in their second cd lol

[Clare C. G]

they probably chose Aaron because he's a great dancer.

[gummiebearz]

lol that's true i suppose :D lol but then he could just dance in the front in the choruses couldn't he? lol and he sung solos more in the songs that never became videos.. right?!

[rannypants]

i was just thinking about posting the same question the other day. There could be many theories...but we might as well not bring them up; They're over.

D:

Although Hannah's voice is awfully adorable in the beginning of 'Searching for Perfection.'

[stacey_frankie]

Although Hannah's voice is awfully adorable in the beginning of 'Searching for Perfection.'

it's not hannah who sings in the beginning but frankie!!^_^

[JTP1708]

Yes, I don't recall Hannah singing that much, but most of the singing was left to Calvin, Frankie, Stacey, Rochelle, and Jay anyhow. ;)

[sc8fan4ever]

Yeah, I know you didn't hear much of Daisy, Aaron, & Hannah, but you hear more from Daisy than from Aaron & Hannah...probably more than them two combined!

[LaraB14]

I think it's the stupid producer's fault. They should have all had a go at singing solo on at least one of the songs that were released, it was like she and the others were shunted aside :bleh:

[gummiebearz]

I think it's the stupid producer's fault. They should have all had a go at singing solo on at least one of the songs that were released, it was like she and the others were shunted aside :bleh:

lol yea i completely agree lol :P all of them should have got a solo at least once in their careers and not those background lines every here and there lol :P but even daisy and aaron had their moments.. i don't ever remember hannah having an actual solo.. or am i wrong? :p

[rannypants]

it's not hannah who sings in the beginning but frankie!!^_^

Oh, really?! I thought she sang that itty-bitty part! lolz, I read that she did in a website where someone noted what kid sang what in the 'Sunrise' album. I know Daisy sang a part in 'Automatic High', right?

I guess they took Hannah in the group because she was adorable and the youngest. The producers wanted kids that would appeal to all ages and she was obviously the right choice...perhaps the right choice in her apperance, but not musically...

[stacey_frankie]

Oh, really?! I thought she sang that itty-bitty part! lolz, I read that she did in a website where someone noted what kid sang what in the 'Sunrise' album. I know Daisy sang a part in 'Automatic High', right?


u mean in the "sundown" album lolz but this is really frankie who sang it!!and yeah daisy sang a part in automatic high and in others songs of the "together" album but not so much unfortunately...:sad:

[rannypants]

u mean in the "sundown" album lolz but this is really frankie who sang it!!and yeah daisy sang a part in automatic high and in others songs of the "together" album but not so much unfortunately...:sad:

lolololerz! OH YES! Dur, how silly of me, 'Sundown'...sorry, got confused with S Club 7's album. D:

[gummiebearz]

lol awww that's ok :D lol we all make mistakes lol :p yea daisy did sing lol and she sang quite a bit in the together album lol but not so much later lol :p

[JTP1708]

lol awww that's ok :D lol we all make mistakes lol :p yea daisy did sing lol and she sang quite a bit in the together album lol but not so much later lol :p

Didn't she open on "One Step Closer?"

[dreaminsimi]

Hannah was always a background member, question: did Hannah do the harmonies on the last chorus of One Step Closer or was it Stacey I haven't got any videos from then and do Daisy and Hannah just mime Frankie's vocals on Don't tell me you're sorry or do they actually sing on it, I don't think they do but I am just checking!Daisy had a lot of solos on together didn't she?The last single she sang solo on was Fool No More on the last chorus harmonies.OK before someone points it out I know I am :offtopic:

[stacey_frankie]

Hannah was always a background member, question: did Hannah do the harmonies on the last chorus of One Step Closer or was it Stacey I haven't got any videos from then

it was stacey!!^_^

[spooky]

Didn't she open on "One Step Closer?"

...the door to the classroom, probably.

[stacey_frankie]

Quotation: JTP1708
Didn't she open on "One Step Closer?"

...the door to the classroom, probably.

looool certainly!!!

that's frankie who opened the song!

[JTP1708]

Quotation: JTP1708
Didn't she open on "One Step Closer?"



looool certainly!!!

that's frankie who opened the song!

lol, I think I was thinking Daisy, but I guess it was Frankie?

[clairebear]

it would have been good if they could have each had a solo on their albums, like Steps always did (except Step One) but considering theres 8 of them and what 15 songs on an album at the most, would only leave 7 songs as a group

[Hownee]

Maybe she was related to someone who chose the groupmembers :p

[Redrose01]

I think the producers picked the people who had the strongest vocals (no offence to Hannah etc) and usually it would be Frankie, Stacey, Calvin and Rochelle.

Maybe she didn't want to sing as much as the others?

I thought she sang solo on one of their b'sides? I think it may have been "We Got You?"

[Daydreamer81]

she never sang solo except for maybe a line. she might of not wanted to sing much as the others, she doesn't really like the spotlight or maybe the management thought she had a weaker voice than the others. remember hannah was picked last along with aaron (who didn't sing a lot either)

[Redrose01]

The only solo I can remember for Hannah was a b-side I think whilst Aaron I think had a few solo's on the Sundown album and a few lines in Sleigh Ride.

[chocy]

she's quite shy believe it or not

[XneverXletXgoX]

is it just more..because when i listen to their songs from the sundown album..when i hear stacey and frankie's solo..more on stacey's..if you listen carefully..you can hear another voice singing along..espcially on sail on through..it's like a sort of whisper..lol..sorry i dont know..it's hard to explain

[Lindsay]

maybe she didn't want to? Maybe she liked the band aspect and just not having her own solo? it's totally possible. it's the reason some people join choir at school, sure they can sing but they dont sing on their own. people are different.

[Daydreamer81]

yeah like me i like to sing with other people singing with me but i don't like to sing a solo alone