PDA

View Full Version : Frankie sing a lot!


Danii
29th Oct 2004, 18:04
I like it when Frankie sing. In the series I dream she sing a lot.
It's great.

Craig
29th Oct 2004, 18:31
Isn't it just. So very beautiful! :wub:

ShyFluffy
29th Oct 2004, 21:33
lol.... yeah well as much as i'm a fan of her.... but i think they should give the other guys some chances..... stacey has a great voice!! and the others too!!.... but still i'm very happy she sings hehe :whistle: :P

AaronsGirl
29th Oct 2004, 22:10
yeah would be nice to hear the others sing as well but frankie singing alot is good

Desiree
30th Oct 2004, 06:47
frankie has an amazing voice. i think i noe why daisy doesnt sing. bcos her voice is like quite high.. if u noe wat i mean. jus imagine.. daisy's voice in wherever u are trying to fit in dreaming? wow tats jus plain weird.

ma5hita
30th Oct 2004, 08:32
frankie got everything! doesnt she?? ^_^ wish i m her.. lol!

Little_Katelyn
30th Oct 2004, 16:16
I love Frankie and I love to hear her sing but I would love to hear Stacey sing and the others!

justsclub
31st Oct 2004, 00:26
ya, frankie seems to be one of the main stars of the show. she sings a lot and is in every episode alot too!

JVC
31st Oct 2004, 16:54
It's very good that Frankie appears in every episode, she's the best character to watch.. and her acting is becoming better and better in each episode
I'm very happy for her :P

Danii
31st Oct 2004, 19:09
Originally posted by ma5hita@Oct 30 2004, 08:32 AM
frankie got everything! doesnt she?? ^_^ wish i m her.. lol!
Yeah, me too.

Danii
31st Oct 2004, 19:10
Originally posted by JVC@Oct 31 2004, 04:54 PM
It's very good that Frankie appears in every episode, she's the best character to watch.. and her acting is becoming better and better in each episode
I'm very happy for her :P
I think so, too.

DJ Drew
1st Nov 2004, 16:37
Originally posted by Craig@Oct 29 2004, 06:31 PM
Isn't it just. So very beautiful! :wub:
Yep! :)

CJA
1st Nov 2004, 21:52
OOOO im in love i just hope my girlfriend doesn't see this post LOL JKING :wub:

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
1st Nov 2004, 22:48
Frankie sings... too much.

Hannah... never sings.

:angry:

ddd99
2nd Nov 2004, 05:22
Hannah... never sings. :lol: You said it.
Frankie can sing the lot. :lol:
The only other two that I miss are Daisy, & Stacey.

Danii
5th Nov 2004, 17:16
I think Frankie sings so much because he has the best voice of the girls.

Greenjp
5th Nov 2004, 18:39
Originally posted by Danii@Nov 5 2004, 12:16 PM
I think Frankie sings so much because he has the best voice of the girls.
No...it's b/c she is Simon's favorite.

Lauren
5th Nov 2004, 22:08
Originally posted by Danii@Nov 5 2004, 05:16 PM
I think Frankie sings so much because he has the best voice of the girls.
ha ha ha....you're off by a long shot. I think Stacey (by far), Roch, and Daisy can all sing better then her. At any rate, Frankie's got a nice voice, but she's not going to win American Idol anytime soon....can't say Pop b/c I don't know how high the standards are. Her singing talent falls somewhere above Britney and below Jojo and Jessica Simpson and much much below Christina Aguilera.

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
5th Nov 2004, 22:26
Stacey has a good little voice. But if there's one thing I really hate is Chrsitina Aguilera's voice.
I've talked to someone who is musician in a great Opera in Paris and he agrees with me. ALL the popstars have in fact bad voices. The only true voices are La Callas, Barbara Hendricks, Pavarotti, etc...
Christina Aguilera would be easily fired from any music school. You think she sings well because we are used to hear a certain type of voice. But it's weak. It's more a scream than a real rising voice.
Nowadays everybody tries to sing and you easily become a popstar because of those tv shows. The level of voice is lower and lower. Believe me.

boule
5th Nov 2004, 22:43
Frankie sings too much in I Dream.

Yes, she's talented, Yes, she has a lovely voice. Yes, she's pretty. Yes, that's why she sings so much and gets so many lines in I Dream. But what? Are the girls ugly? Do they sing out of tune? Do they have horrible voices? No. So this is not a good reason.

Greenjp
6th Nov 2004, 06:38
Originally posted by Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)@Nov 5 2004, 05:26 PM
Stacey has a good little voice. But if there's one thing I really hate is Chrsitina Aguilera's voice.
I've talked to someone who is musician in a great Opera in Paris and he agrees with me. ALL the popstars have in fact bad voices. The only true voices are La Callas, Barbara Hendricks, Pavarotti, etc...
Christina Aguilera would be easily fired from any music school. You think she sings well because we are used to hear a certain type of voice. But it's weak. It's more a scream than a real rising voice.
Nowadays everybody tries to sing and you easily become a popstar because of those tv shows. The level of voice is lower and lower. Believe me.
Whoa... :whistle:...if we go by that standard I guess Celine Dion and Barbara Streisand can't sing either :rolleyes:

ddd99
6th Nov 2004, 07:41
Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
I think you've made a big mistake of talking to a classical musician about pop music. Why don't you ask a pop musician what they thing of opera, & La Callas, Barbara Hendricks, Pavarotti, etc...
You'll get the same bs.
La Callas, Barbara Hendricks, Pavarotti, etc...have true voice, please kill me now. :lol:

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
6th Nov 2004, 13:04
Are you kidding me ? I don't think I'll have the same answer. popstars must have nothing but respect for tenors. Popstars have popstars voices, that is to say standard voices.

Now Mariah Carey can sing very high and Celine Dion (I hate her) but she's perfectible.
Now I can't make technical analysis of Aguilera's voice because I don't know how to say it in english but I can explain in French. "Sa voix dérape quand elle monte dans les aigus. Elle n'a pas le vrai trémolo quand sa voix monte. Elle est un peu criarde."
If you understood it's good because for me it's impossible to say it in english.

Lauren
6th Nov 2004, 14:33
I can't read French so I don't know what you said, but Christina can def sing. Maybe in some songs she screams, but even if she does, she can sing as well. Her songs are amazing! "The Voice Within" and "Reflection" no one denies that Christina can't sing! Other people are questionable but not her! I love Mariah Carey and Whitney Houston as well, they are so amazing I have all of Whitney's (even 1 record!) and almost all of Carey's/

It's too bad, the clubbers don't really do anything vocally impressive in their CDs, sometimes Stacey does and rarely Daisy has...I think it's because since they didn't intend for the juniors to become a real band, they turned away some more talented people...I mean I like Calvin and Aaron but I can pull guys that can sing like them off street in dozens.

boule
6th Nov 2004, 15:25
Originally posted by Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)@Nov 6 2004, 01:04 PM
"Sa voix dérape quand elle monte dans les aigus. Elle n'a pas le vrai trémolo quand sa voix monte. Elle est un peu criarde."

Moi, j'ai compris. A part un truc: c'est quoi un trémolo?

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
6th Nov 2004, 17:04
c'est la manière dont tu fais vibrer ta voix

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
6th Nov 2004, 17:07
To Lauren :

I don't think they have to be vocally impressive. They don't sing great slows. They have the right voice for what they sing : simple and pure pop music.

In_The_Shadows
6th Nov 2004, 17:19
Originally posted by Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)@Nov 5 2004, 10:26 PM
Stacey has a good little voice. But if there's one thing I really hate is Chrsitina Aguilera's voice.
I've talked to someone who is musician in a great Opera in Paris and he agrees with me. ALL the popstars have in fact bad voices. The only true voices are La Callas, Barbara Hendricks, Pavarotti, etc...
Christina Aguilera would be easily fired from any music school. You think she sings well because we are used to hear a certain type of voice. But it's weak. It's more a scream than a real rising voice.
Nowadays everybody tries to sing and you easily become a popstar because of those tv shows. The level of voice is lower and lower. Believe me.
thats just what u think. the fact that the person u asked agrees dosent make it true u know.

numbcanadian
7th Nov 2004, 00:04
Originally posted by Lauren@Nov 6 2004, 02:33 PM
I can't read French so I don't know what you said, but Christina can def sing. Maybe in some songs she screams, but even if she does, she can sing as well. Her songs are amazing! "The Voice Within" and "Reflection" no one denies that Christina can't sing! Other people are questionable but not her! I love Mariah Carey and Whitney Houston as well, they are so amazing I have all of Whitney's (even 1 record!) and almost all of Carey's/

It's too bad, the clubbers don't really do anything vocally impressive in their CDs, sometimes Stacey does and rarely Daisy has...I think it's because since they didn't intend for the juniors to become a real band, they turned away some more talented people...I mean I like Calvin and Aaron but I can pull guys that can sing like them off street in dozens.
yeah, i think christina has an amazing voice as well, but she just dresses skan*y. Stacey's voice is unique and all butterfly-ish and sweet. No offense, but Frankie's voice is kinda normal. I mean, she's above average for singing but her voice isn't astounding. But that's what you usually have when you put 8 people together, not every single one of them is going to have the best voice in the world. Daisy's voice is also very unique and i quite like it! I really like Calvin's voice too. I think it would be so sexy if he played acoustic guitar with a song he wrote.. ^_^ (he already plays guitar, so let's hope he writes some songs!!)

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
7th Nov 2004, 00:11
Originally posted by In_The_Shadows@Nov 6 2004, 05:19 PM
thats just what u think. the fact that the person u asked agrees dosent make it true u know.
No I'm sure it's really true, it's common sense. I've been studying music for ten years. I'm not always right, but here I can say I 'm right. Believe me.

But Christina Aguilera can sing a lot of things, for sure, I agree on that point. The problem is when I hear Justin Timberlake saying "Christina Aguilera is the most beautiful voice in the world". It's a bit too much.

vixens_lounge69
7th Nov 2004, 15:10
Originally posted by numbcanadian+Nov 6 2004, 08:04 PM--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (numbcanadian @ Nov 6 2004, 08:04 PM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'> <!--QuoteBegin-Lauren@Nov 6 2004, 02:33 PM
I can't read French so I don't know what you said, but Christina can def sing. Maybe in some songs she screams, but even if she does, she can sing as well. Her songs are amazing! "The Voice Within" and "Reflection" no one denies that Christina can't sing! Other people are questionable but not her! I love Mariah Carey and Whitney Houston as well, they are so amazing I have all of Whitney's (even 1 record!) and almost all of Carey's/

It's too bad, the clubbers don't really do anything vocally impressive in their CDs, sometimes Stacey does and rarely Daisy has...I think it's because since they didn't intend for the juniors to become a real band, they turned away some more talented people...I mean I like Calvin and Aaron but I can pull guys that can sing like them off street in dozens.
yeah, i think christina has an amazing voice as well, but she just dresses skan*y. Stacey's voice is unique and all butterfly-ish and sweet. No offense, but Frankie's voice is kinda normal. I mean, she's above average for singing but her voice isn't astounding. But that's what you usually have when you put 8 people together, not every single one of them is going to have the best voice in the world. Daisy's voice is also very unique and i quite like it! I really like Calvin's voice too. I think it would be so sexy if he played acoustic guitar with a song he wrote.. ^_^ (he already plays guitar, so let's hope he writes some songs!!) [/b][/quote]
totally agree with everything you say. 'specially the comment 'bout calvin... :wub:

In_The_Shadows
10th Nov 2004, 18:14
Originally posted by Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)+Nov 7 2004, 12:11 AM--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah) @ Nov 7 2004, 12:11 AM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'> <!--QuoteBegin-In_The_Shadows@Nov 6 2004, 05:19 PM
thats just what u think. the fact that the person u asked agrees dosent make it true u know.
No I'm sure it's really true, it's common sense. I've been studying music for ten years. I'm not always right, but here I can say I 'm right. Believe me.

But Christina Aguilera can sing a lot of things, for sure, I agree on that point. The problem is when I hear Justin Timberlake saying "Christina Aguilera is the most beautiful voice in the world". It's a bit too much. [/b][/quote]
thats an opinion, its what kind of voice u like.
there is no low, that the person with the most amazing voice cant b a pop singr

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
10th Nov 2004, 19:23
Ok if you want. But I was just pointing out that she was not technically speaking an excellent voice. It's more about technique than about a matter of likes and dislikes.
That's all. I think a lot of persons can sing her songs way better than her.

shockbody
10th Nov 2004, 19:23
Originally posted by Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)@Nov 6 2004, 01:04 PM
Are you kidding me ? I don't think I'll have the same answer. popstars must have nothing but respect for tenors. Popstars have popstars voices, that is to say standard voices.

Now Mariah Carey can sing very high and Celine Dion (I hate her) but she's perfectible.
Now I can't make technical analysis of Aguilera's voice because I don't know how to say it in english but I can explain in French. "Sa voix dérape quand elle monte dans les aigus. Elle n'a pas le vrai tremolo quand sa voix monte. Elle est un peu criarde."
If you understood it's good because for me it's impossible to say it in english.
Mariah Carey, mieux que Christina Aguilera? Mariah Carey elle fait rien que gueuler. On dirait un chat torturé. Je crois que c'est plutot elle qui est un peu criarde, non? Et c'est tres tres dur a croire que Celine Dion chante mieux que Christina. Elle n'est pas du tout exceptionelle a mon avis. Mais bref.

I have to agree with everything you said, Lauren. Especially the comment about JoJo. She's an amazingly good singer, and I would absolutely love to see the S Clubbers [try to] sing some of her songs. Individually.
I don't mean to be rude, yeah, but I don't think that any of the S Clubbers can really sing, apart from Stacey. Heck, even I can sing as well, if not better than Frankie. Alright, I don't really *know* if she can sing, but so far, she hasn't sung anything exceptionally hard. Her voice is quite nice to listen to I agree (nothing spectacular though), but her pitch..as I said, I don't know about it, but judging from what I've heard she's just average. I think it's very unfair for the S Clubbers, especially Stacey who can actually *sing*, to not have a fair part in singing, in the show.

boule
10th Nov 2004, 19:27
Originally posted by shockbody+Nov 10 2004, 07:23 PM--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (shockbody @ Nov 10 2004, 07:23 PM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'> <!--QuoteBegin-Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)@Nov 6 2004, 01:04 PM
Are you kidding me ? I don't think I'll have the same answer. popstars must have nothing but respect for tenors. Popstars have popstars voices, that is to say standard voices.

Now Mariah Carey can sing very high and Celine Dion (I hate her) but she's perfectible.
Now I can't make technical analysis of Aguilera's voice because I don't know how to say it in english but I can explain in French. "Sa voix dérape quand elle monte dans les aigus. Elle n'a pas le vrai tremolo quand sa voix monte. Elle est un peu criarde."
If you understood it's good because for me it's impossible to say it in english.
Mariah Carey, mieux que Christina Aguilera? Mariah Carey elle fait rien que gueuler. On dirait un chat torturé. Je crois que c'est plutot elle qui est un peu criarde, non? Et c'est tres tres dur a croire que Celine Dion chante mieux que Christina. Elle n'est pas du tout exceptionelle a mon avis. Mais bref. [/b][/quote]
Pour moi elles sont toutes les trois des gueuleuses. :ph34r: Enfin! :whistle:

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
10th Nov 2004, 19:33
Tu as écouté Christina essayé de monter dans les aigus ? Sa voix dérape. Je ne sais si tu as fait de la musique mais moi c'est lÃ* où j'ai appris plein de choses. Mariah Carey peut-être qu'elle gueule mais elle gueule comme Cecilia Bartoli ou d'autres chanteuses d'Operas (peut-etre pas aussi bien mais c'est le meme nombre d'octaves et le meme genre de vibrato). regarde la chason dirty de Christina Aguilera on dirait qu'elle chante avec une moto dans la gorge. Personnellement, j'ai de plus en plus de mal avec sa voix. ELLE est criarde. Mariah Carey peut gueuler de toutes les façons sa voix vibre de façon naturelle. Ce n'est pas une affaire de goût car j'aime beaucoup le premier album de Christina et j'aime de moins en moins la musique de M Carey. C'est juste un commentaire technique.

shockbody
10th Nov 2004, 19:34
Ouai, mais quand meme, faut dire que Christina Aguilera gueule moins que Mariah Carey.

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
10th Nov 2004, 19:35
Si tu veux dire monte moins haut dans les octaves je te dit oui.

shockbody
10th Nov 2004, 19:36
Originally posted by Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)@Nov 10 2004, 07:33 PM
Tu as écouté Christina essayé de monter dans les aigus ? Sa voix dérape. Je ne sais si tu as fait de la musique mais moi c'est lÃ* où j'ai appris plein de choses. Mariah Carey peut-être qu'elle gueule mais elle gueule comme Cecilia Bartoli ou d'autres chanteuses d'Operas (peut-etre pas aussi bien mais c'est le meme nombre d'octaves et le meme genre de vibrato). regarde la chason dirty de Christina Aguilera on dirait qu'elle chante avec une moto dans la gorge. Personnellement, j'ai de plus en plus de mal avec sa voix. ELLE est criarde. Mariah Carey peut gueuler de toutes les façons sa voix vibre de façon naturelle. Ce n'est pas une affaire de goût car j'aime beaucoup le premier de Christina et j'aime de moins en moins la musique de M Carey. C'est juste un commentaire technique.
Je sais tres bien que c'est pas une affaire de gout, je suis bien d'accord. Mariah Carey peut gueuler, mais Christina Aguilera peut chanter.

shockbody
10th Nov 2004, 19:37
Originally posted by Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)@Nov 10 2004, 07:35 PM
Si tu veux dire monte moins haut dans les octaves je te dit oui.
Je parlais a boule.

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
10th Nov 2004, 19:40
T'exagères un peu lÃ* ! Dire que Mariah Carey ne sait pas chanter c'est un peu trop. J'ai toute sa discographie chez moi et même si tout n'est pas parfait, je te promets elle sait chanter.

shockbody
10th Nov 2004, 19:42
Originally posted by Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)@Nov 10 2004, 07:40 PM
T'exagères un peu lÃ* ! Dire que Mariah Carey ne sait pas chanter c'est un peu trop. J'ai toute sa discographie chez moi et même si tout n'est pas parfait, je te promets elle sait chanter.
J'ai pas du tout dit que Mariah Carey elle sait pas chanter. Et t'a rien a me promettre, je peux tres bien decider pour moi meme.

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
10th Nov 2004, 22:22
ok fais comme tu veux :no:

Lauren
11th Nov 2004, 00:16
This isn't fair...someone translate this stuff! :(

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
11th Nov 2004, 11:02
He says he prefers Christina's voice to Mariah Carey's. And that Mariah only screams. I answered "You're exaggerating a little".

shockbody
11th Nov 2004, 13:08
lol Sorry Lauren. We're having an argument over who sings better, Christina Aguilera or Mariah Carey. And Mariah can sing, I'm not denying that fact, but when she does that high pitched screaming thingy, it makes me cringe. And because Christina doesn't do that in her songs, it doesnt mean she can't sing as well, if not better. I prefer singing, not screaming. Some may say that the "screaming" can be classified as singing, and it probably is, but I don't think so.

EDIT: Btw Mesmero, it's a she, not a he.

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
11th Nov 2004, 14:22
ok ;) where are you from by the way ?

shockbody
11th Nov 2004, 14:29
I'm from England.

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
11th Nov 2004, 14:48
Tu n'es pas française ?

shockbody
11th Nov 2004, 17:01
Non lol. Je suis etudiante a une ecole francaise n'empeche. le system francais est con.

mrs.goldspink
11th Nov 2004, 17:02
i'm a big fan of her 2,but it would be nice 2 hear the others 2

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
11th Nov 2004, 17:44
Parce que tu parles très bien le français. C'est hallucinant.
Cela fait combien de temps que tu étudies cette merveilleuse langue ?

*krysten
11th Nov 2004, 21:48
Originally posted by mrs.goldspink@Nov 11 2004, 09:02 AM
i'm a big fan of her 2,but it would be nice 2 hear the others 2
yeah, i agree with ya!

stratusfied
11th Nov 2004, 22:33
Yeah is great but a little unfair for the rest of the members lol

Lauren
12th Nov 2004, 04:46
Thanks shockbody and mesmero for the translation!

Ahh Mariah I think she's a lovely singer but sometimes she does that wispy voice too much. Just sing girl!

At least Frankie's a good performer when she sings. I like that. :) She's much better then Calvin and Hannah! But even so, I'd still love to her Hannah's voice sometime, so her being in the band is not a total waste!

shockbody
12th Nov 2004, 10:54
Originally posted by Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)@Nov 11 2004, 05:44 PM
Parce que tu parles très bien le français. C'est hallucinant.
Cela fait combien de temps que tu étudies cette merveilleuse langue ?
Eum..j'ai commencé l'ecole a 2 ans, et j'ai 14 ans, alors ça fait 12 que je fais mes études en français.

shockbody
12th Nov 2004, 11:03
Originally posted by Lauren@Nov 12 2004, 04:46 AM
Thanks shockbody and mesmero for the translation!

Ahh Mariah I think she's a lovely singer but sometimes she does that wispy voice too much. Just sing girl!

At least Frankie's a good performer when she sings. I like that. :) She's much better then Calvin and Hannah! But even so, I'd still love to her Hannah's voice sometime, so her being in the band is not a total waste!
It's like Hannah can't really be bothered when she dances. I don't know why, but lately she's just been irking me whenever I see her. I still don't see the point of her being in the band. It's like, there are millions and trillions of kids out there with great talent, and they choose one who does absolutely nothing in the band. It's just annoying.

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
13th Nov 2004, 01:05
Again I have to disagree with you. I think she would like to do some stuff but she's not the boss. The Boss is called Simon Fuller. He has the power to choose who will sing. Hannah can sing, but he just doesn't want her to. Why ? I really don't know. I don't think there is a good reason.

shockbody
13th Nov 2004, 01:48
Yeah, I guess it's not her fault. But then again, who knows? Maybe he doesn't want her to sing because she hasn't got a great voice, maybe not. Anyhow, Fuller's an idiot.

Lauren
13th Nov 2004, 02:07
Maybe this makes me a bad person :( but if I was in the band I'd be annoyed with Hannah for taking up paycheck. But what I really worry about is doesn't she feel bad for not having a solo, I mean it's the perfect insult if you're mad at her, and when she tell her kids (if she has any) about being in S Club, they're gonna want to know why she doesn't sing...heck everyone wants to know that.

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
13th Nov 2004, 18:31
I think it's part of what Fuller really wants to do. The only members who sing are people's favourites : Frankie and Calvin at the moment. I don't think he's an idiot because musically he offers what's the best in pop music (spice girls, s clubs). He's just a business man but he's not an idiot.

Greenjp
14th Nov 2004, 06:54
Originally posted by Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)@Nov 13 2004, 01:31 PM
I think it's part of what Fuller really wants to do. The only members who sing are people's favourites : Frankie and Calvin at the moment. I don't think he's an idiot because musically he offers what's the best in pop music (spice girls, s clubs). He's just a business man but he's not an idiot.
Yes those 2 are popular but look at the song dreamin..so mono-tone and their voices sound like all the edges have been filed off..you know they are sing but it's more like a blunt whisper...Why have your 2 best sing this ....am I making sense here???

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
14th Nov 2004, 19:08
I agree. Dreaming is very monotonous.

niftyclo
14th Nov 2004, 20:43
I agree, he needs to stick to his winning formula. The most popular s club 8 song are the pop - y, fun, dancey etc songs (OSC & Sundown), & i don't think Dreaming is that, but i will say the song has grown & grown on me & now i REALLY like it!

Mesmero (devoted to Lady Hannah)
14th Nov 2004, 22:22
Wow you're lucky ! :(

Lauren
14th Nov 2004, 22:22
I think that SC8 can give Calvin and Frankie alot of screentime without making them sing all the time. Because they aren't the best singers and it's one of the reason's why Dreamin isn't a very good song. They can just always be in the front row, or in interviews...or something.

dreamingirl
15th Nov 2004, 14:00
yeah its really good frankie sing a lot!!!! she's look soo pretty! :wub: :cool:

hanny17s
15th Nov 2004, 22:35
Originally posted by ShyFluffy@Oct 29 2004, 09:33 PM
lol.... yeah well as much as i'm a fan of her.... but i think they should give the other guys some chances..... stacey has a great voice!! and the others too!!.... but still i'm very happy she sings hehe :whistle: :P
I agree with you

Lauren
21st Nov 2004, 02:00
Frankie's so radiant when she sings :)

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v17/roxystarfish/cin008.jpg

bestclub8
21st Nov 2004, 07:51
Frankie has sung some type of solo in all of their singles, well of course not Puppy Love, but she did in Sleigh Ride(sp?) .
Opened One Step Closer
2nd solo Automatic High
opened New Direction
Opened Sleigh Ride
Opened Fool No More
2nd solo Sundown
2nd solo Dont Tell Me Your Sorry

Calvins_girl
21st Nov 2004, 10:52
thats a really good point, she seems to get all the good parts in all the songs and she did have a chunk in sleigh ride as well...and here we go the secret single!

Lauren
21st Nov 2004, 21:59
She wasn't so great in Automatic High. I think her part is the worst of the song...but it's not as bad as Wherever You Are. I thought she almost ruined that song! :pinch: But in other songs she's pretty good. She probably did the best in Sundown, FNM, and ND.

Calvins_girl
22nd Nov 2004, 21:31
she was really really good in ND, i thought it was probably her best part so far

sclubber22
2nd Dec 2004, 03:38
i only like her in FNM and ND

rafinalalita
3rd Dec 2004, 10:42
i like sail on through.. i think her part is really cool

vixens_lounge69
3rd Dec 2004, 18:51
Well since she basically sings in almost every song, I don't think I could choose. Lol... I think she has a really nice tone to her voice. It's strong but sweet, ya know?

sclubber22
4th Dec 2004, 04:18
i prefer rochelle's voice to hers actually but rochelle didnt sing as much as in the sundown album

rafinalalita
4th Dec 2004, 08:59
yea.. and so is daisy.