hannahs weight!:(

[xxfrankiexx]

hey! i have been reading that people dont like hannah because she is overweight!! i think the other are too skiny and that she is normal! lol what do you lot think?? -_-

[mcbusted]

Hannah isn't exactly skinny, but i don't think she's overweight. She's average and I think the others are really skinny.

I like Hannah, she's so cute :)

[Cutecare]

Hannahs in between tho but shes a little bit bigger than the others but its now a bad thing cause it makes her seem more "normal"

[mguj1130]

she looks fine

[xxfrankiexx]

yer! lol i love hannahhh!! i fink she is perfect! lol

[hanny17s]

I think she is great.... I mean the other girls are extra skiny but Hannah is a normal girl...
I don't know why people bother on say that

[Pink Angel]

I think that Hannah is just fine how she is!
Some people are really judgemental about people because of their weight, and I think that it's wrong! If you like someone, you like them no matter what, and it's their personality that matters, not what they look like!

Siobhan

[hanny17s]

I think that Hannah is just fine how she is!
Some people are really judgemental about people because of their weight, and I think that it's wrong! If you like someone, you like them no matter what, and it's their personality that matters, not what they look like!

Siobhan



Totally agree with you

[SportzChick]

I don't think Hannah is overweight at all. Its just that the other girls are really skinny (not anorexic skinny tho) so Hannah always gets compared to them

[sc8_girl39]

i think hannah is a healthy gal! she's really pretty, and she is more curvy. i think i may have her image...like the figure.

she always gets compared to the other girls because she's always with them and people critisize her all the time. she's not overweight at all! she's wonderful!

[KateyGirl]

i think it's great that she's not uber skinny like the other girls. she looks more normal in some respects. people really need to re-assess their definition of "fat" or "overweight" if they're even considering calling hannah this.

[stargirl05]

^totally agree with you. I don't think Hannah is fat or overweight. She is curvy and perfectly healthy.

[LeahT]

I like Hannah 'cause she's curvy like me!

[vixens_lounge69]

Amen. Like alot of people have said, Hannah's not overweight at all. The other SC8 girls are quite skinny... And when being in a band with them, she's of course going to be compared, and people would think she is "fat" or "overweight" compared to them, but she really isn't. If you take a walk through your local mall, you'll most likely find girls who are very curvy like Hannah is. She's got a thicker, more curvacious body type, but she's no where near "fat" or "overweight."

[LeahT]

Besides, the camera adds 5 pounds. Therefore she's probably even thinner in person.

[AaronsGirl]

i dont think hannahs overweight shes just normal

[mylovelil]

this is not the first time we talked about it, rite?
hannah is defenitely NOT overweight--she is HEALTHY
but sadly,we cant change other ppl's point of view.

[xxfrankiexx]

no!!! i didnt start this topic because i think she is fat! i was just say!!

[meganbell04]

i think theres nothing wrong with hannahs weight at all. people saying that are just being picky and they are probably just jealous of her curves

[algiscl]

Hannah is a very beautiful girl. :love:

[Pextip]

Hannah is a very beautiful girl. :love:
exactly (minus the :love: )

[algiscl]

why?

[hannahs2aaron]

omg...hannah is a beautiful gal (as everyone had sed), i can't believe people r so judgemental...i tthink Hannah is better than others with her figure... da others r just skinny.... never just a book by its cover.... not matter wat others fink... it's da inside dat counts

[ztaimz]

hannah has: gorgeous face, lovely hair, wonderful smile, beautiful eyes and most of all a fantastic figure. there's nothing wrong with her at all

[clairebear]

Shes only 14 yrs old for heavens sake!!!
let her grow up without giving her a complex .shes a pretty girl!

[smallman28]

People think she is "fat" cause she is standing next to 14-16 old skinny girls!
She is "normal" it is more likely the others are a bit too thin and will put on some more weight as they get a bit older.
Stand her next to an older person and she sure wont look "fat"

[rafinalalita]

she is just fine.. at least she is happy with herself not like some people and in the end bacame aneroxia

[xxfrankiexx]

yup she is v. pretty :P

[XXmcflyXX]

yerrr she is very prettty girl!!

[Stepstar90]

Being overweight, i think is when your weight effects your health, ye shes chubbier than before but hey she looks fine!

[sclub8_canada]

i think it's very hyocrytical(don't know how to spell it) because a lot of people critize others for their weight, but on the other hand tell people that it's alright to not be "normal" or get angry when OTHERS critize THEM! :crazy:

[hannahroxalways]

I dont think Hannah is over weight either

[sc8german]

Hannah is normal and not overweight. The others are skinny and she's evertime compared
with the others, so some people think she's overweight.

[yoinkster]

heh, I'm completely obsessed with Hannah, I think she's beautiful !!
fat people are like 20stone, and I doubt Hannah's even half that ...
she's perfect just the way she is with that smile, hair and character, I'd die to know someone as cool as her.

[wicked_sab]

hannah will never be fat she will always be the same old hannah

[xxfrankiexx]

yer aww lil hanz

[lexo1]

i dont think shes over weight nor do i think the other girls are '' skinny '' they are what they are ant that is girls who are naturally how they look.

[ChArLoTtE SC8 fan]

Hannahs fine!, she has a bit more shape which makes her stand out, shes pretty!!!

[Cutecare]

I just think she still has some baby fat on her...but she'll grow out of it and even if she doesnt shes alwayz gonna look good!

[wicked_sab]

yer i think its just babe fat it will go wen she gets older

[Cora]

I think she's normal weight, it's just that the camera adds 10 pounds.

[Lauren]

Actually it's not baby fat, Hannah actually got bigger as she got older...she was thinner as a junior.

I guess that you can just say that Hannah is curvy, she could pretty well a plus-size/full-figure model cuz they're always girls that are larger then normal but still not really fat and she falls into that category perfectly.

[wicked_sab]

yer i hate camra they always make u look like ur fat we ur not

[CaitlinLynn]

awww.... hannah's perfect!!! She's the normal teenager size!!! Rochelle's just really tall so that's why she's thing, frankie works out alot(she's starting to get abs, i thnk ) Daisy's always been tiny and so has stacey!!! That's why i like hannah, she's normal!!! and absolutly beautiful!

[Lissie]

I think Hannah is the only girl in the band that is "normal". Like the same size as any girl in her age that you see at the mall in the "real world", but that it's just probably the other girls that is really thin. It's nothing wrong with that, Hannah is perfect as she is and so are the other girls

[Sarcasm]

She doesn't need to lose weight.

And if people have seen the two recent pics of her spreading around the people who trade rare/exclusive pics she has lost some weight around her face like her cheeks are skinny and stuff. But then again she didn't need to lose weight in the first place!

[Nicole_sc8]

I think that she is average. The other girls in the band are so thin that it makes Hannah look bigger. She is completely normal.

[wicked_sab]

yer hannah fine shes not big in any way but shes gettin prettier everyday wat do u guys think

[pop_music_fan]

Hananh is gorgeous. There isn't a "perfect" or "imperfect" body. She has a great figure. She's got a curvy body. Sure, she might have a more curvacious body than the other girls but so? that's how god made them. and she's healthy and fit from dancing all the time. so I reckon it's fine.

[Amadeus]

I Just can say anything... Hannah is very lovely... I'd love her smile... :lol: And... is perfect for me :lol:

[StepsMaddness]

All i'm gunna say is Danny from McFly thinks Hannah is fit, need i say more!! and shes perfect just the way she is, shes not conformed to the stereotype that singers have to b anorexic thin, shes an insparation to other girls showin that u dont have to b stick thin to be gorgeous cause i'm sure ur all agree Hannah is gorgeous!

[frankie°]

People should just leave her alone shes not fat, just fink she might come on this site n shell feel really upset if she does come on ere

[numbcanadian]

ok lookee. have you SEEN the other girls in the band?! Stacey is REALLY skinny, Daisy's naturally petite, Frankie's slim....Hannah and Rochelle are just curvy and there's nothing wrong with that. Hannah is definitely NOT fat at all, she's normal. She's just constantly surrounded by the rest of the girls who are skinnier than Hannh by comparison but that does not man that Hannah is fat. So everyone, just drop it.

[Madam Helga]

I think Hannah looks absolutely gorgeous at her natural size, which really isn't fat AT ALL, just normal

[lexo1]

ok lookee. have you SEEN the other girls in the band?! Stacey is REALLY skinny, Daisy's naturally petite, Frankie's slim....Hannah and Rochelle are just curvy and there's nothing wrong with that. Hannah is definitely NOT fat at all, she's normal. She's just constantly surrounded by the rest of the girls who are skinnier than Hannh by comparison but that does not man that Hannah is fat. So everyone, just drop it.
if stacey is ''really skinny'' which she is not :mad: then so are frankie & daisy & i thought i read somewhere stacey said she can eat whatever she want's & stay as she is & frankie has to watch what she eat's. or maybe it might be other way round but i dont think so. anyway like i have said before none of them have anything to worry about when it comes to weight as realisticaly they havent gained or lost a load of weight since they first came on the scene.so in short they are all naturally the shape & size that they look so none of them should ever feel the need to be ashamed of that or feel pressured to gain or loose weight which they might do if they ever came on to this site & read this topic. :rant: :p

[XXmcflyXX]

true!! and hannah is very pretty i wish i was like her

[Amadeus]

"true!! and hannah is very pretty i wish i was like her"

RIGHT!!! :lol:

[rafinalalita]

why people comment something bad about them.. they are just fine and they are happy being them then we should be happy for them too

[XXmcflyXX]

"true!! and hannah is very pretty i wish i was like her"

RIGHT!!! :lol:



yer wat is your problem i waS JUST AGREEING WIT HER AND ID DO ANTHING TO LOOK LIKE HANNAH SHE HAS NATURAL BEAUTY :bleh:

[Cutecare]

and plus if you have a fast/high metabolism then ure gonna be skinny vs someone who has a slow metabolism...you cant help it...i have a fast metabolism and im around 5 feet and i weigh 95 pounds...its not that i dont eat it's just that the weight doesnt stay on me...so maybe that should be considered before people make some assumptions that it's cause they eat to much or they dont eat enough..

[sc8_girl39]

ok lookee. have you SEEN the other girls in the band?! Stacey is REALLY skinny, Daisy's naturally petite, Frankie's slim....Hannah and Rochelle are just curvy and there's nothing wrong with that. Hannah is definitely NOT fat at all, she's normal. She's just constantly surrounded by the rest of the girls who are skinnier than Hannh by comparison but that does not man that Hannah is fat. So everyone, just drop it.
uhh.. i've been saying this for ages and no one has ever bothered to listen to me. now it seems as if everyone here tries to bash hannah. omg it bothers me soo much. she's NORMAL. FACE IT. if you still think she's fat, its your problem. because majority of people think that she's perfectly fine. and don't say she doesn't do anything because she does. get over it.

[Cora]

Yea, compared to everyone else in the band, she does look alot bigger. But compair her to someone of NORMAL weight and she looks fine. I don't even get why her weight is such a big deal, it's not like she's obese or anything.

[numbcanadian]

exactly! :)

[sc8_girl39]

and we all know that she's not even close to obese because in everything that she's in, she looks perfectly fine. but i guess all of those hannah haters out there have tunnel vision, or they definately see totally different things than normal people do.

[*SteFie*]

hannah is not overweight..whoever said that needs their eyes checked! she's just fine!...she's like me..we're petite and not overweight!..i'm only a 100pounds!

[mcc05]

i actually think that apart from frankie and daisy hannah is alot better looking than many young celebs now a days.

i think that as she is still young compared to the others in a couple of years times she may be even better looking than she already is.

[Roxy]

Even nor I'm as skinny as Frankie, I think Hannah's normal, there's nothing wrong with her, and it's only muscles, not fat, she's not overweight!
I think she looks gd and I would wanna luk liek her... okay I would luv to luk liek Daisy or Frankie, or Stacey, but Hannah's okay, she's not fat!

[XXmcflyXX]

Even nor I'm as skinny as Frankie, I think Hannah's normal, there's nothing wrong with her, and it's only muscles, not fat, she's not overweight!
I think she looks gd and I would wanna luk liek her... okay I would luv to luk liek Daisy or Frankie, or Stacey, but Hannah's okay, she's not fat!
i totally agree wit you there:) its just muscle if not its baby fat dat wil pass wen she gets older BUT... she still looks fine and pretty i wuld neva say she is obese those ppl r like 20 stone and hannah must be more than half dat and compared to the other girls shes better cos she looks like a normal gir who doesent work out just to make urself thin as a stick

[lexo1]

its just muscle
and it's only muscles,
not sure if she would take that as a compliment :lol2:

[yoinkster]

she may be even better looking than she already is.

omg, is that possible ?! wooooow, that would seriously kill me if perfection got better :dance: :thumbsup: :love: :love: :love:

[xxfrankiexx]

omg, is that possible ?! wooooow, that would seriously kill me if perfection got better :dance: :thumbsup: :love: :love: :love:

awww cute!! lol :lol2:

[hannah]

i don't think she's overweight...I only think she's a bit "bigger" than the other girls...but if you like her,you have to like the way she is!!

[emeraldeyez]

why would anyone even mention her weight? shes fine the way she is! if your a fan you wouldn't talk about it and not mention it at all!

[kales]

why would anyone even mention her weight? shes fine the way she is! if your a fan you wouldn't talk about it and not mention it at all!
yup....you said all I was going too..Id love to have her figure ^_^

[mandyx]

Hannah really isn't overweight, she's only being compared to the other girls of the band. I mean, just look at Stacey for example (Nothing agaisnt her! I love her!!) she's almost as skinny as a stick! Plus, Hannah is only 14, she's still got a lot more time to grow. I think she'll grow taller and she'll look skinnier then. Not that she's fat of course!

[Emily]

i used to b her size and i didn't like it coz all my friends were like way too skinny so i went on a major diet and i went a bit too far,i really regret it. that's all i'm saying.hannah is perfectly fine the way she is!she does not need to lose weight or go on a diet!don't critisise her 4 her weight,it means nothing!DON'T JUDGE PPL BY THEIR WEIGHT COZ U MIGHT PUSH THEM TOO FAR! :cry:

[emeraldeyez]

ya didn't u people know that when u get older u slim out??? ya, it's true... it happened to me :)

[FoxyJack]

The one time you nitced she was fat was in sundown i think on pop world and she word a black and white skirt and im sorry but her legs where HUGE. And everybody noticed it.

[cRazy_ovEr_sc8]

who cares if she's overweight or not? we love her for who she is, not bcoz of her weight/appearance... besides she looks cute and adorable the way she is now... :dance:

[franx4me]

hannah isn't overweight at all.. i think i agree to whoever sed that she is just being compared with the other girls in sc8 (such as my Frankie):love: hehe... frankie is so hot and hannah is pretty , plus that's a good point on how her age is 14.

[Mk613]

all the girls are lovely in their own unique way just like all the other women and young women in the world. personally i think hannah is pretty cute

[sclubber5678!]

she's fat, cant dance, cant sing... o wait i couldnt tell if she can sing coz she never does.

[Andrew5]

she's fat, cant dance, cant sing... o wait i couldnt tell if she can sing coz she never does.
:lol:

So True!

[franx4me]

maybe just give her a chance before you judge her, cause she does sing and dance just like the other s clubbers

[Stepstar90]

Hannah is just a backing singer

[franx4me]

yea but still, people can't criticise her for being fat or ugly or anything because really, hannah is a great singer and dance. Other wise why did she get picked in the first place?That obviously means she has talent and she is just a person who can't sing or dance and be pathetic... give her chance every one... and her weight is fine, it's not like she's obese or anything.. she is still young..

[Clare C. G]

there's nothing wrong with her weight. she's probably going through a `puppy fat` stage that every teenager gets. i bet even the other S Club 8 girls have gone through that stage.

[hanny17s]

she's fat, cant dance, cant sing... o wait i couldnt tell if she can sing coz she never does.

I think you are being mean... you should stop looking what is worng with the people and start looking the good side of them :mad:

[hanny17s]

The one time you nitced she was fat was in sundown i think on pop world and she word a black and white skirt and im sorry but her legs where HUGE. And everybody noticed it.

:mad: people don't have respect anymore.... I don't think she is fat... actually she is not she look great on that performance shame on you if you can't see it

[redlightning371]

this thread is taking a turn for the worst :crazy: . who cares about her weight , hannah is really pretty. and as far as her singing goes, she obviously isn't the best, but why criticize her for that? she wasn't one the original 7 picked for the group, so maybe she was picked for her personality :thumbsup: . is that so hard to understand?

[Stepstar90]

Personally I dont think there's anything wrong with her weight! Although i havent seen recent pictures, but even if she was ugly thats also a personal/individual opinion and could be said about any of the S Club 8 gals or guys etc!

[sclubber5678!]

yea but still, people can't criticise her for being fat or ugly or anything because really, hannah is a great singer and dancer. Other wise why did she get picked in the first place?That obviously means she has talent and she is just a person who can't sing or dance and be pathetic... give her chance every one... and her weight is fine, it's not like she's obese or anything.. she is still young..


ok, what? she can NOT dance! she always screws up the dance routine and ruins the performance. way to go hannah! give yourself a pat on the back!

[Andrew5]

ok, what? she can NOT dance! she always screws up the dance routine and ruins the performance. way to go hannah! give yourself a pat on the back!
Exactly right. None Of The Other Members seem to have problems on the dance moves..

And honestly who just stands there when they forget there moves. Its not like they are actually singing as well ;) she could just move her lips and wave her arms around and nobody would even care :P

[kales]

Reading this thread makes me sick....call yourself fans? I dont think so..your calling her fat and ugly? Id like to see you lot....and they have all messed up routines before...so go back and check ok?

Hannah is a stunner and if she ever read her fansites she'd be really upset to read this stuff Im sure...she got picked cause she has talent and natural beauty..she doesnt need tons of makeup and lots of flashy clothes to stand out....she is amazing and stands out for her beauty and talent... Ive never read something as shallow as this thread...really I havnt

and whats this about her legs? are you lot thick? girls legs get wider when they grow..it varies in teenagers...and if thats what you call fat...gos knows whats your definition of slim... honestly...

[Andrew5]

Reading this thread makes me sick....call yourself fans? I dont think so..your calling her fat and ugly? Id like to see you lot....and they have all messed up routines before...so go back and check ok?

Hannah is a stunner and if she ever read her fansites she'd be really upset to read this stuff Im sure...she got picked cause she has talent and natural beauty..she doesnt need tons of makeup and lots of flashy clothes to stand out....she is amazing and stands out for her beauty and talent... Ive never read something as shallow as this thread...really I havnt

and whats this about her legs? are you lot thick? girls legs get wider when they grow..it varies in teenagers...and if thats what you call fat...gos knows whats your definition of slim... honestly...

Ok Hannah Really Dosent have that many fans, which makes there not be many fansites. People only like her because she was 'cute' as a child.

Yes, the other have messed up on routines, but dont make it THAT obvious, and actually stop what they are doing.

Talent? Ha! Im not so sure that she actually can sing. All she is is strictly eye candy, Just as Aaron is. There was a decision made based on singing and dancing ablility, both of which were not in the final cut.

The reason they were let in a few days later, is because the producers thought it through, and realized that the band could get more fans if they had eye candy.

Hannah has not exactly got the smallest legs. They are fat, not muscle

[sclubber5678!]

really! look how skinny dasiy's, frankie's, stacey's, and rochelle's legs are! hannah's are mammoth!

[kales]

you discust me

[whois]

Alright, that's quite enough. Play nice or don't play at all.

[xxPinkGurliexx]

Omfg You Call Your Selves Fans?????? I Do Not Know How You Dare .... Andrew5 Hannahs Legs Are Not Fat And Sclubber5678 How Dare You Call Her A Mommoth And Say She Cant Dance And Screws The Routine Up ... They All Have Calvin Isn't The Best Dancer Either As They Stated In The Story!!! You Want Shooting I'm Telling Ya Whats Up With Your Legs Like? I Bet They R Like Sring With Knots In Or Massive Thunder Thighs And In Real Life You Would Never Say That To Hannah Your Just Using The Net To Make You Feel Self Secure. If Hannah Read This How Do You Think She Would Feel? You Think She'd Be Over The Moon That Your Calling Her Fat? No I Don't Think She Would She'd Be Hurt And Upset.... You Want To Take One Great Big Look At Your Self And Pick Out Your Faults Cause Everyone Has Them But Is There Any Need For Comments Like This??? No



Hannah If You Read This Just Letting You Know You Have Fans Out There Just Ignore The Shallow Minded People. Kyles Xx

[Hannahrules]

Hannah is not untalented and everyone makes mistakes, so who really cares if she misses a step or 2

[Lissie]

I thought this was a fan forum. Some of you are so shallow... I can just imagen what you guys look like, cause most people who goes on bashing other peoples looks normally have serious issues about how they look themselves.
And you those who said she cant sing and dance.... do it better yourself!! You arent in a famous pop band, are you? No, so keep your mouth shut.

[xxPinkGurliexx]

Go Lissie! Thants right keep your mouthes shut if you have nothing nice to say don't say anything at all ..... were you lot brought up with manners? ..... clearly not!

[Hannahrules]

Andrew do you not look at aaron when he dances?

[Andrew5]

Andrew do you not look at aaron when he dances?
Better Dancer Then Hannah ;)

If hannah had talent, we would see much more from her.

end of story

[Clare C. G]

someone should just lock this post up. it's getting on my nerves! LEAVE HANNAH ALONE! SHE'S A NORMAL TEENAGER AND THERE'S NOTHING WRONG WITH THAT!

[whois]

Haven't got the time to keep track of this today. Closing now, before it gets worse.